What's the Difference Between an Electric Acoustic and an Acoustic Guitar?
How to Choose One as a Beginner and Key Points When Upgrading

A Thorough Explanation of the Basic Differences

Are you unsure whether to choose an “Electric Acoustic” or an “acoustic” guitar? While they look similar, their construction and ideal uses are completely different. In this article, we’ll explain how to find the perfect guitar for your playing style.

1. The Three Key Differences Between Electric Acoustic and Acoustic Guitars

Acoustic guitars and Electric Acoustic guitars. At first glance, they may look like similar instruments made of wood, but there are key differences in their internal structures. Here, we’ll explain the three major characteristics that distinguish them, drawing on expert insights.

1-1. Presence or Absence of a Pickup (Microphone)

The most fundamental difference between an acoustic guitar and an Electric Acoustic guitar is whether it has a built-in microphone—called a “pickup”—that converts the vibration of the strings and the resonance of the body into an electrical signal. A standard acoustic guitar has no such mechanism; the sound resonating within the body’s cavity (soundhole) travels directly through the air to your ears. It can be described as a musical instrument that is purely a product of woodworking.

On the other hand, Electric Acoustic guitars come equipped with a built-in pickup to capture the sound. The most common type is the “piezo pickup,” which is embedded beneath the saddle—the part that supports the strings. Since this piezo element directly detects physical changes in pressure from the strings, it is highly resistant to feedback (the phenomenon where the microphone picks up the sound coming from the speaker, causing a high-pitched “screech”).In recent years, an increasing number of Electric Acoustic guitars have adopted a dual-system design that incorporates a small condenser microphone inside the body to capture a more natural, airy sound, making them an extremely practical choice for live performances.

1-2. Ability to Shape the Sound with a Preamplifier

If you look at the side of an Electric Acoustic guitar’s body or the rim of the soundhole, you may notice a control panel embedded there with small knobs and an LCD screen. This is the “preamp” (preamplifier). Naturally, acoustic guitars do not have this electronic circuitry.

The electrical signal picked up by the pickup is extremely weak, so if sent directly to an amplifier or mixer, it would be overwhelmed by noise. The preamp serves to amplify this weak signal to a usable level.Furthermore, since it allows you to adjust the volume at your fingertips and features an equalizer (EQ) function to balance treble, midrange, and bass, you can instantly adjust your tone to suit the acoustics of the venue where you’re performing. Many models also have a convenient built-in tuner, allowing you to tune smoothly right at your fingertips during a live performance.

1-3. Amp Connection Jack and Power

To output electrical signals externally, the bottom of the Electric Acoustic guitar’s body (typically an end-pin jack integrated with the strap pin) is equipped with a jack for plugging in a guitar cable. In the case of acoustic guitars, there is simply a wooden or plastic pin protruding from the body.

Additionally, a power source is required to power the preamp mentioned earlier. Many Electric Acoustic guitars have a battery compartment located somewhere on the body for a 9V rectangular battery (Type 006P) or AA batteries. Since the amplifier will stop producing sound once the battery runs out, checking the battery beforehand is an essential routine for players who use Electric Acoustic guitars. (*Note: There are also some passive-type Electric Acoustic guitars that do not require batteries.)

2. Characteristics, Advantages, and Disadvantages of Acoustic Guitars

A pure acoustic guitar is a complete instrument that produces a rich sound solely through the vibration of wood, without any electrical power. Let’s take a closer look at the advantages stemming from these characteristics, as well as the disadvantages in today’s music scene.

2-1. Advantages of Acoustic Guitars (Rich Natural Sound and Ease of Use)

The greatest appeal of the acoustic guitar is, without a doubt, the “richness of its natural sound” (sound not amplified through a speaker).Since there are no built-in pickups, wiring, or heavy battery compartments inside, the top and back plates can vibrate freely without restriction. The sensation of the natural harmonic components inherent in tonewoods—such as Sitka spruce, Indian rosewood, and mahogany—spreading from the soundhole throughout the entire space is a blissful experience unique to the acoustic guitar.

Another major advantage is the convenience of not needing any peripheral equipment—such as power sources, cables, or amplifiers. The flexibility to take it out of its case and start playing the moment the mood strikes is a huge motivator for practicing at home or jamming out a quick song.

2-2. Disadvantages of Acoustic Guitars (Volume Limits and the Challenge of Miking)

On the other hand, acoustic guitars face a physical barrier known as the “volume limit.” While the volume is more than sufficient for playing in your own room, when performing in a band setup with drums and Bass, or when trying to project sound to an audience in a large live venue, the acoustic guitar’s natural sound alone simply cannot cut it.

To amplify the sound of an acoustic guitar during a live performance, you need to place a microphone—similar to a vocal mic—in front of the guitar to pick up the sound. However, this method significantly restricts the player’s freedom of movement, as the volume changes the moment the player moves even slightly away from the microphone. Furthermore, there is always the risk that the guitar body will pick up the loud sound coming from the venue’s speakers, causing severe feedback.For live house sound engineers (PA), it is considered an extremely difficult task to make the sound of a mic-ed acoustic guitar stand out clearly amidst the band’s mix.

Acoustic Guitar Inventory List

Staff Comments

Even though we simply call them “acoustic guitars,” your options vary greatly depending on your musical genre and the sound you want to achieve!
Each one is packed with elements that, once you get hooked, you won’t be able to put down—it’s a lot of fun!
If you’re just vaguely thinking, “I’d like to try playing an acoustic guitar,” we recommend starting with a folk guitar!

3. Features, Pros, and Cons of Electric Acoustic Guitars

Electric Acoustic guitars have evolved to meet modern needs—such as live performances and streaming—by solving the “challenge of achieving high volume” inherent in acoustic guitars. Here, we’ll explain the appeal and structural features of Electric Acoustic guitars, which excel in a wide range of settings, from the stage to home recording.

3-1. Advantages of Electric Acoustic Guitars (Suitability for Live Performances, Streaming, and Home Recording)

The overwhelming strength of the Electric Acoustic guitar lies in its ability to connect directly to an amp or PA system with a single cable and produce a clear sound at any volume. You’re not tethered to a microphone, so you can move freely around the stage while delivering an energetic performance.

Furthermore, uses that have surged in recent years include live streaming via PC or smartphone, as well as home recording for DTM (Desktop Music).If you try to record a pure acoustic guitar with a condenser microphone, it will pick up room reverberations, air conditioner noise, and even the sound of cars passing by outside—making it difficult to achieve a clean recording unless you have a dedicated soundproof environment. With an Electric Acoustic guitar, however, you can simply plug the cable directly into an audio interface and record or stream professional-quality, clear guitar tracks late at night without worrying about ambient noise at all.

3-2. Disadvantages of Electric Acoustic Guitars (Limitations on Natural Sound and Power Management)

While Electric Acoustic guitars are extremely convenient, there are cases where the “pure acoustic tone” is sacrificed as a structural trade-off. Many models are designed so that the body does not resonate excessively—with intentionally thick top plates and sturdy bracing (internal framework)—to prevent feedback even when exposed to loud speaker sounds on stage.In addition, many models feature a “cutaway” design—where a section of the body is hollowed out—to make it easier to play the higher frets. However, because this reduces the body’s volume, the bass response tends to be less powerful than that of a standard acoustic guitar.

Furthermore, they come with the hassle of managing battery life before a performance. Every Electric Acoustic guitar player has experienced the frustration of the battery suddenly dying—causing the sound to cut off abruptly—while practicing in the studio or during a live performance. This requires the discipline to always keep a spare battery tucked away in your guitar case.

Electric Acoustic Guitar Inventory List

4. Which One Is Right for You? How to Choose a Guitar Without Regrets

Now that you understand the construction, pros, and cons, which one should you choose when it comes time to buy your own guitar so you won’t regret it? Here, we’ll suggest practical selection criteria tailored to your lifestyle and future plans.

 

4-1. For Singing and Playing at Home or as a Hobby: “Acoustic Guitar”

If you want to “play and sing your favorite songs at home” or “enjoy playing guitar at a leisurely pace as a weekend hobby,” we definitely recommend a pure acoustic guitar. If you don’t plan on plugging into an amp, choosing an acoustic guitar where the cost saved on pickups and preamps has been invested in higher-quality wood and precision craftsmanship will ultimately result in better sound quality.Choose your preferred body size—such as a Dreadnought or OM (Orchestra Model)—and savor the rich, resonant sound that fills the room. That beautiful natural tone will be your greatest motivation to keep playing for years to come.

4-2. If You’re Planning to Perform Live, Stream, or Record: Go for an “Electric Acoustic”

If you have clear goals—such as “I want to play at live music venues or on the street in the future,” “I want to stream videos of myself playing and singing on YouTube or social media,” or “I want to create original songs on my computer”—it’s overwhelmingly smoother to purchase an Electric Acoustic guitar from the start.In modern music, there will inevitably be times when you need to “digitize” your guitar sound or “amplify it to high volumes.” In those situations, with an Electric Acoustic guitar, you can move on to the next step immediately—simply by plugging in a single cable—without having to worry about investing in additional equipment or dealing with complicated setups.

4-3. The Third Option: Retrofitting a Pickup to an Acoustic Guitar

Among intermediate to advanced players who already have guitar experience and are particularly particular about the natural sound, the most standard approach is to “purchase a high-quality acoustic guitar and install a professional-grade, high-quality pickup later.”

Instead of the mass-produced pickups that come standard on off-the-shelf Electric Acoustic guitars, you’ll have a trusted luthier install a high-performance pickup—such as those sold separately by L.R. Baggs or FISHMAN, which cost tens of thousands of yen and include features like the ability to blend piezo and microphone signals.With this approach, you’ll end up with the ultimate instrument—one that delivers superb “line sound” on stage without compromising in any way on the top-tier “acoustic sound” that Martin and Gibson are renowned for. While there are initial costs and installation fees involved, this is the most highly recommended option for experienced players who want a tone that will last a lifetime.

Staff Comment

One of the most frustrating yet enjoyable parts of choosing an acoustic guitar is the time spent considering specifications like materials and body shapes!
The points above are merely general trends; we don’t claim that any particular guitar is “unsuitable” or “can’t be used” for a specific genre.
Don’t overthink it—it’s perfectly fine to start by picking up any guitar that catches your eye!

Summary

The difference between an Electric Acoustic and an acoustic guitar lies not only in whether it has an amp output, but also in the resonance of its natural sound and the breadth of its uses. Assess your current playing style and future goals, and try to find that ideal guitar—one that will accompany you on your musical journey for years to come—from the wide range of options available.

Guitar Inventory List

Author: Mochizuki (Advance Guitars Staff)

In my personal life, I mainly play electric guitar. Drawing on my boundless love and interest in music—so much so that I keep playing guitar even during work breaks—I share the appeal of acoustic guitars using some of Advance Guitars’ finest strumming techniques.

Qualifications and Experience: 4 years as a musical instrument appraiser

▶︎Read my articles here:
The Secrets of the Ovation Adamas
The Legend of Terry Nakamoto: Yamaha’s Four Heavenly Kings

If you found this article helpful, please show your support!